The Sims Wiki:Requests for administratorship: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Content added Content deleted
imported>Woganhemlock (→Conclusion: let's finish this) |
imported>Woganhemlock (→Conclusion: how do i into indent) |
||
| Line 195: | Line 195: | ||
::Second I have the concept of "deserved v. a tool given". I'll ake this clear as crystal, '''rights are given to trusted users, they aren't an award'''. Sure, I can see the mistake some people may make but its like saying "Good job on your math test Billy you're the principal now". It doesn't work like that. |
::Second I have the concept of "deserved v. a tool given". I'll ake this clear as crystal, '''rights are given to trusted users, they aren't an award'''. Sure, I can see the mistake some people may make but its like saying "Good job on your math test Billy you're the principal now". It doesn't work like that. |
||
::Thirdly, and I'm getting to the end now, is we need to define consensus. Generally consensus is around two-thirds support, but also strength of argument is an important factor as well. The votes are currently 8 support, 7 oppose and 2 neutral. For this I'm going to ignore neutral votes. We have 53% support here. While this is indeed over half, its not really consensus. One thing I have also noticed is that the majority of the support votes generally have weaker arguments for them, generally "she deserves it". While not everyone said this it is a general trend. The oppose votes, meanwhile, are much more well thought out and have stronger arguments. |
::Thirdly, and I'm getting to the end now, is we need to define consensus. Generally consensus is around two-thirds support, but also strength of argument is an important factor as well. The votes are currently 8 support, 7 oppose and 2 neutral. For this I'm going to ignore neutral votes. We have 53% support here. While this is indeed over half, its not really consensus. One thing I have also noticed is that the majority of the support votes generally have weaker arguments for them, generally "she deserves it". While not everyone said this it is a general trend. The oppose votes, meanwhile, are much more well thought out and have stronger arguments. |
||
:With all this in mind, there is more reasons against Hana recieving adminship than there is for. Therefore, I'm going to be '''declining''' this request. I'm also going to be closing this discussion as I can see it escalating into a petty squabble that will get nowhere. Thank you everyone for voting. {{WHsig|06:13, May 10, 2013 (UTC)}} |
::With all this in mind, there is more reasons against Hana recieving adminship than there is for. Therefore, I'm going to be '''declining''' this request. I'm also going to be closing this discussion as I can see it escalating into a petty squabble that will get nowhere. Thank you everyone for voting. {{WHsig|06:13, May 10, 2013 (UTC)}} |
||